As a Grade 5 English teacher, I selected ChatGPT and Google Search as two candidate tools. Both can support lesson preparation, but they need to be checked before classroom use.
| Tool | Possible use | Passed checks | Issues/flags | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tool A: ChatGPT | Prepare Grade 5 English worksheets, vocabulary activities, reading comprehension questions and grammar quizzes. | Accuracy: Can provide useful ideas, but answers need checking. Privacy: Can be used without entering pupil information. Accessibility: Simple instructions and different levels of activities can be prepared. Appropriateness: Activities can be adapted to Grade 5. Language/cultural fit: Can include Nepali and local examples when prompted. | It may give incorrect answers, use unfamiliar examples or produce biased content. It also requires internet access. | Use with safeguards. Check all answers against the CDC textbook, avoid sharing personal data and adapt activities to students' needs. |
| Tool B: Google Search | Find official Grade 5 English textbooks, CDC teacher guides, learning materials, pictures and grammar resources. | Accuracy: Official sources such as CDC are available. Privacy: Searching general educational topics does not require pupil data. Accessibility: Provides different types of learning resources. Appropriateness: Resources can be selected according to Grade 5 level. Language/cultural fit: Nepali and local educational resources can be found. | Not every website is reliable. Some resources may be too difficult, outdated or culturally unsuitable. Advertisements and unrelated content may distract learners. | Use with safeguards. Prefer official and trusted educational websites, check the content and select age-appropriate materials. |
Final Reflection
Both tools can support my teaching, but neither should replace a teacher's professional judgement. I will check AI-generated information with textbooks and trusted sources, protect students' personal information, and adapt materials to local language and culture. My guiding principle is: AI helps, but a person decides.