For my Grade 4 English lesson on phonics, particularly words with silent letters, I have selected ChatGPT and Wordwall as two candidate tools.
| Tool | Possible use | Passed checks | Issues/flags | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. ChatGPT | Generate word lists, simple explanations, examples and practice activities for silent-letter words. | Accuracy: Can provide useful examples, but needs teacher verification. Privacy: Can be used without entering pupils' personal information. Accessibility: Easy to access with an internet connection. Appropriateness: Useful for preparing age-appropriate activities with teacher guidance. Language/cultural fit: Can provide English examples, but some outputs may need local adaptation. | May generate incorrect examples or explanations. Requires internet access, and its responses should not be shared with students without checking. | Use with safeguards |
| B. Wordwall | Create interactive matching games, quizzes and word-sorting activities using silent-letter words. | Accuracy: Teacher can check all questions and answers before sharing. Privacy: Activities can be created without using pupils' personal details. Accessibility: Simple and engaging, but requires a device and internet access. Appropriateness: Suitable for interactive practice. Language/cultural fit: English activities can be customised using familiar words and examples. | Some features require a paid subscription. Access may be difficult for students with limited devices or internet connectivity. | Use with safeguards |
My overall judgement
I would use ChatGPT to prepare and adapt learning materials and Wordwall to provide interactive practice. However, I would check all AI-generated content before using it. I would also provide printed activities or group-based alternatives for students who do not have access to digital devices. Most importantly, I would ensure that technology supports learning rather than replaces teacher guidance and student thinking.